It is said that Seitan was invented by Buddhist Monks looking for a palatable meat substitute that would appeal to vegetarians and meat eaters alike. In essence, it is wheat protein. It can be made by making a big ball of wheat dough out of whole wheat flour and washing all the starch out by repetitively kneading and rinsing the dough under water until all that is left is the gluten.
I am not that ambitious.
I do love homemade seitan, however, and this is how it's done in my house.
This recipe is adapted from Vegan with a Vengeance by Isa Chandra Moskowitz
2 cups vital wheat gluten
1/4 cup nutritional yeast
2 tbsp all purpose flour
1 cup cold vegetable broth
1/2 cup tamari
1 tbsp ketchup
1 tbsp olive oil
2 cloves garlic, pressed
12 cups of vegetable broth
1/2 cup tamari
Step 1: Dump all dry ingredients into a bowl and mix together [I find a Kitchenaid Stand Mixer works well for seitan making, but you can do this by hand as well]
Step 2: Stir together all the wet ingredients and garlic (DO NOT include the cooking liquid)
Step 3: Mix the wet ingredients into the dry ingredients
Step 4: Let the mixer mix it for a few minutes, OR knead by hands for a few minutes. It should look like brains.
Step 5: Take your brain-tan and form it into a log-style shape and let it rest for 5-10 minutes
Step 6: Using a serrated knife, slice the seitan into 4-6 pieces. You should have nice small air pockets inside
Step 7: The Cooking Step.
There are as many ways to cook seitan as there are to eat it! Ok, maybe not, but you do have a bunch of choices.
The easiest and most traditional way is to drop your seitan pieces into a large pot containing your cooking liquid (cold). Bring the water to a boil then IMMEDIATELY turn down to a very low simmer and cook, covered, for about an hour or until the seitan floats. Poke it around every now and again to make sure it doesn't stick to the bottom of the pot.
Then there is the dry-bake method, coined "Seitan O'Greatness." This method produces a much firmer, more dense seitan. With this method, stop at Step 5 and roll your seitan up in aluminum foil, tightly twisting the ends to make a big aluminum sausage. Bake in the oven at 325 for an hour and a half. Don't be alarmed if the foil explodes in the oven. (Oh who am I kidding, it's pretty alarming! But not messy. Just wrap your ends tighter next time and maybe use more foil. Those super wide heavy duty foils are great for this.
"Mexican Style" Seitan O'Greatness with tomato paste, lime juice and zest, cumin, paprika, and cilantro:
You can slice this stuff really thin!
Then there is my variation on the stovetop liquid method which yields a very tender seitan, but takes twice as long. Take your seitan and wrap each piece in cheesecloth and tie with butchers string (bet you didn't think there was use for that in a meg*n kitchen!) and then proceed as with the first method. After one hour, untie the packages and put the seitan back in simmering for another hour. This produces a nice dense tender seitan, and moister than the dry-bake method.
Seitan Cheesecloth Bundles:
All the kids in the pool!:
Dense, yet moist. A thrilling combination:
And yet another wet variation of my own devising. This one was inspired by Alton Brown's Baked Barley. He bakes barely so that the temperature around it stays steady and the water never just boils away. Fascinating. If it's good enough for Barley, it's got to be good enough for seitan, right? Right.
Put your seitan pieces in the pot with your cold cooking liquid. Bring it to a boil on the stove THEN take it OFF the stove, put the lid on, and stick it in your pre-heated 350 degree oven. (Don't try this with pots that aren't oven safe. If you don't have oven proof cookware, transfer the seitan and hot liquid VERY CAREFULLY to a casserole dish with a lid and put THAT in the oven. Very Carefully.)
Bake for about 1 hr and 15 minutes or until your seitan is all floating.
This yields wonderfully tender seitan.
STILL TOO CHEWY??
One more variation to try...
Replace the cup of vegetable broth in the seitan wet mix for 1 cup of pureed silken tofu. Ohh man, that seitan will MELT in your MOUTH!
As for the spices... mix it up a bit! Experiment with different herbs and spices and liquids and cooking liquids and heck, even cooking methods, until you find one that works for you. So you have a few batches of inedible seitan? So what? Live and learn.
After cooking, whatever method you choose, Seitan will firm up in the fridge overnight, so try to plan ahead. If you've cooked it in liquid, store it in some cooking broth in the fridge until you're ready to use it. If you aren't going to use it in the next three days, stick it in the freezer. Unlike tofu, Seitan come out of the freezer just like it went in.